Preloved
ClassifiedsForumsReviewsMembersThe Joy of Second Hand

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure

Messages 161 to 180 of 3857.

« Previous  1  ...  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  ...  193  Next »


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 3:48 PM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi Clive

Yes, private sales are subject to the same law. However, you would have to prove that the seller was aware of the problem. This might prove difficult to establish. First, ensure that the vin is original. Also if you have the service history check with previous servicing dealers. Last but not least & the most important if you are successful, can the seller repay you.

Good luck


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 3:55 PM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi Graham

yes clearly they aknowledged within 14 days. If you don't already know may I suggest that on the 28th day you check with the court by phone & if they miss the deadline apply immeadietly for summary judgment.

Good luck


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 5:18 PM
Graham
Joined 1 Jun 2005
16 posts

I agree with Cris although I am not sure the full extent of the sale of goods act applies as I don't think you are treated as a "consumer" when the seller is also a private individual. There is the buyer beware concept which would make it v difficult to sue unless there had been some representation / statement as to the head gasket (as Cris implies).

Cris, yes I have it in the diary to ring and then go for default judgment. They can defeat this if they can establish they need more time etc but in a simple claim about a failed engine it will be hard for them to do so. Graham


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 8:43 PM
-  Edited by Jon 13 July 2005, 8:46 PM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi Graham

Yes even if you did obtain a judgment they could apply to have it set aside. However they would have to have a strong argument as to why the Court should grant such an application. After all the rules are there to be followed by all of the parties. Also they are a defendent with greater funds defending against an ordinay member of the public. If they should ARGUE for more time, going from the date of your letter of intent & not the summons, I would argue that they have had more than enough time to prepare & any delay would place a further & unjustified financial burden upon you. Again Good luck


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 10:48 PM
-  Edited by clive 13 July 2005, 10:50 PM
clive
Joined 5 Jul 2005
7 posts

Cris.
Thanks for the reply. I dont think that anybody is aware of the impending failure of these engines, our car was in good order with a good service history, i had only checked the water/oil the day before and the car had only travelled a total of 16 miles on the day it gave up. I think that the only way anybody in my situation is likely to get any compensation for an engine that only survives for 40% of its expected life is that this whole situation is continually brougt up in the public eye as a mass action and Land Rover are forced to back down. It is not only the cost of replacement engines however but the rapid depreciation of the vehicle which will get a lot worse as the problem becomes more widely known. Clive


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 11:29 PM
Mark
Joined 5 Jul 2005
20 posts

Hi Clive,

As in my case, I agree entirely with your comments.

The cylinder head gasket can fail at any time and without warning on these engines.
My Freelander had a replacement engine at 59,000 miles and this unit then failed at 85,000 miles.
Prior to the failure the vehicle had been used “around town”; South Wales to Essex a couple of times, basically any and every type of journey and never lost coolant or used any oil. It was a shopping trip of some 2 miles when the gasket failed!

As I mentioned in an earlier thread, my depreciation on the vehicle was some £6500 over two years, and dealers are already aware of the potential problems with the model, most choosing not to “retail” them.

I wouldn’t wish a petrol Freelander on my worst enemy!

Mark


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 11:31 PM
junklander
Joined 1 Jul 2005
32 posts

I agree Clive. Although individual legal action against LR dealers is one option, it doesn't focus attention on the real problem, and in the long run will keep this issue as an individual battle against LR. The fact is LR has marketed and expensive product with a fundamental design flaw. There is enough evidence out there to suggest that every single k-series 1.8lt engine will fail due to slippage of the cylinder liners. This sounds like a possible class action to me. For the individual (due to the potential cost of this problem), LR will need to be dragged screaming and kicking though the courts to face reality. That is ofcourse if court action is successful. What big companies fear most is poor public opinion which may have a detrimental effect on sales. I understand however the Rover group has folded. Where does that leave the consumer?

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
13 July 2005, 11:46 PM
junklander
Joined 1 Jul 2005
32 posts

Cris, you made the point "you would have to prove that the seller was aware of the problem." It is my understanding (through questions put directly to LR Australia), that replacement engines sold to Freelander owners (pre 2001) are exactly the same engines as fitted at time of vehicle manufacture. I was told by LR that the modified engines for current models is not compatible with the earlier Freelanders. I have 2 documents issued by LR which identify the cylinder liners as a fault. Bulletin 0036 issued 18 June 04 aknowledges the potential failure and says "if the cylinder liners have dropped below the block face, the engine must be replaced". So, my point is: LR is selling a product which by their own admission is faulty. Is this enough proof that they are "aware of the problem"? For most of us the real problem is not the failure of the first engine, it is finding the money to buy the second engine....which we know will fail again and we suspect LR knows it will fail again....... Terry.

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
14 July 2005, 0:43 AM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi Junklander

Rover group is not Landrover they parted some time ago

Landrover is owned by Ford & still very much in business


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
14 July 2005, 1:03 AM
-  Edited by Jon 14 July 2005, 1:15 AM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi Junklander

Yes I understand your point the problem is that a negligence claim will be very costly. The plan I am formulating at the moment is the possibility of a number of owners issuing proceedings in the county court against their supplier on the same day. I would expect the press to pick this up (they would certainly be made aware) & the ensuing publicity might be just what is needed. In addition, & notwithstanding the aforegoing, I also am at present taking Trading Standards to task. When I 1st spoke with them the adviser stated it was a civil matter however I suggested that LR continuing to sell a vehicle with a known serious defect might actually be a criminal act. I will be speaking to them again. I have pointed out that they exist to protect the consumer & rather than individuals taking costly action, they should be the organisation taking action against LR. I'll let you know the outcome

Re: the private sale. There is case law, the 1st involved a house sale, placing a duty upon the seller to disclose such matters. Lets face it what buyer would ask "do the cylinder liners slip"


Adverts Currently On Preloved - Place an ad here for free


FOR SALE
Ford Ranger XLT Double Cab - New Shape Pick Ups 2007 (07)
Croydon, Surrey, UK
  FOR SALE
Mitsubishi Pajero 4x4 SWB Turbo Diesel
Wantage, Oxfordshire, UK
 
FOR SALE
Ford Explorer 4x4 LPG low tax, low running costs
Coalville, Leicestershire, UK
  FOR SALE
W REG KIA 4X4
Wallasey, Wirral, UK
 
 
[More 4x4 ads...]

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
14 July 2005, 5:54 AM
junklander
Joined 1 Jul 2005
32 posts

Hi Cris,

As I am in Australia I guess I won't be participating in the county court proceedings, however I hope that a positive result will have a a flow on effect for owners outside the UK.

On the matter of trading standards I think it is important to appreciate that when The Freelander first went to market with the k-series engine, no one, not even Land Rover was aware of the engine defect - so no breach of the trading standards there. On 18 June 04 Land Rover issued a Technical Bulletin identifying the fault. My argument is that if a trader, having established and documented a product defect, continues to trade that product, they would surely be in breach of the Trade Practices Act. I can understand that a manufacturer can produce a faulty product - that in itself is probably not an illegal act, however trading laws must surely be breached if that manufactuer fails to take action when a major fault is identified.

Terry.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
14 July 2005, 9:31 AM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi Junklander

I'm not sure without checking but I think LR were well aware of the design fault well before the date you mention. Don't forget this engine had been around some time & was fiitted to many rover cars which I recall suffered simular problems.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
18 July 2005, 0:53 AM
Gavin
Joined 11 Jul 2005
38 posts

They knew about this in 2001. I will post a Land Rover Technical document proving this on my improved website shortly (will be updating Monday/Tuesday night)

I've also made the link to this easier, see:

http://freelander.webhop.net


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
18 July 2005, 12:21 PM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi

Graham could you contact me at the Freelander Action Commitee direct

e-mail [Log in to view email]


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
20 July 2005, 10:40 AM
Gavin
Joined 11 Jul 2005
38 posts

To All

It seems that Cris might have got the attention of UK Trading Standards. It is important that everyone that can send details of their experience with Land Rover and their dealers. He also needs to get in touch with Graham urgently.

Please take a look at:

http://freelander.webhop.net

Thanks

Gavin



Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
21 July 2005, 12:56 PM
Phil
Joined 21 Jul 2005
5 posts

My Freelander 2000 V6 Head gasket failed and sure enough, the local dealer reports I need a new engine, but no engines are available in the UK!! After two weeks of waiting an engine finally arrives. Once fitted the dealer then reports a series of problems, the G Sensor, the radiator needs replacing, the rear diff needs replacing and rear shaft mounts are failing..Landrover are contributing towards the engine cost, but the additional costs have pushed the repair over £2000...not impressed and will never go near a Landrover again nor recommend one

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
21 July 2005, 8:36 PM
Matt
Joined 17 May 2005
13 posts

Good work Cris and Gavin.

I have been in touch with the SMMT Society for Motor Manufacturers and Traders regarding my case and they want to take it up. I'm currently just sending them my information so will let you know the outcome, but it may be worth us all contacting them so that they know that its not an isolated case and take it more seriously!
You can submit your case online http://www.smmt.co.uk - click on consumer advice.

Worth a go!!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
21 July 2005, 10:40 PM
junklander
Joined 1 Jul 2005
32 posts

Thanks Matt, I will do that now.

Thanks also to Gavin...the web site is looking great.

For the information of Freelander victims in Australia: the ACCC is now collecting data on this matter. They have already received several complaints and agree that a pattern is emerging. They have agreed to contact Land Rover. I strongly encourage you to put your story in writing to the ACCC office in your state.

Addresses can be found at:
http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.p......fromItemId/3634

Terry.



Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
22 July 2005, 0:52 AM
-  Edited by Jon 22 July 2005, 0:59 AM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Hi Matt

The problem with expecting the SMMT to act in your interests is a little misplaced. Of course I wish you the best & would be most pleased to hear you've been successful.
Nevertheless, everyone has spent a great deal of time, not to say money, pursuing their individual cases. Also the more time that passes without positive action the harder it will be to obtain recompense. I'm suggesting that for us approaching SMMT now is an unecessary distraction.
May I also take this opportunity to offer you some advice Plead your case to the SMMT by simply presenting your evidence. I suggest the you should not try to quantify your financial loss until liability, in full, has been accepted by your dealer. Please remember SMMT represent the dealers & manufactures not consumers like you. Also if they have given you the impression that they are unaware of these problems, this is incorrect Finally, If your not already a member of the action commitee please join via Gavin's web page


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
22 July 2005, 1:04 AM
-  Edited by Jon 22 July 2005, 3:59 AM
Jon
Joined 6 May 2005
387 posts

Phil

Whats the age of your Freelander? Did you purchase new?
Do you have FSH? Whats your mileage?

Please join the action commitee via Gavins web page, as linked to his posting on this site, & we wilI be able to offer confidential advice.


Messages 161 to 180 of 3857.

« Previous  1  ...  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  ...  193  Next »

 

Important Note

All messages are submitted by visitors to this web site, and represent their own personal opinion. They do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of Preloved.

You use this information at your own risk. Preloved can not be held responsible for any damages or loss resulting from the use of this site. Please see our Terms and Conditions for more details.

Not a member yet?

Why not join the fun for free! Members can sell their stuff completely free of charge, have searches prioritised for their local area, and lots more.

Join for free | Member Log In
Are you a fan of Preloved?

If so, why not help us spread the Joy of Second Hand by joining us on Facebook. [more...]