Preloved
ClassifiedsForumsReviewsMembersThe Joy of Second Hand

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure

Messages 3541 to 3560 of 3875.

« Previous  1  ...  172  173  174  175  176  177  178  179  180  181  182  183  184  ...  194  Next »


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 9:19 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

also stewart i read somewhere you need to put a PRT thermostat on when doing headgasket job

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 9:29 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Stewart.

We have fitted around 50 MLS headgaskets to the K series Freelander since the introduction of the MLS upgrade , since that time we have not had 1 repeat failure ....there are several reasons for this imo.

Firstly , the headgasket by design is more naturally robust and is able to cope and withstand a greater temperture range , the effects of an air lock in the cooling system on these vehicles with the old style head gaskets fitted was catastrophic .

Secondly , we do not cut corners.... the original problem is diagnosed and rectified as necessary...you have already said this in a previous post and is very important . Protusions need to be measured , water pumps etc should be replaced , in the event of emulsification the whole cooling system should be flushed and if necessary remove the dash to clean the heater core ( matrix ) and replace coolant pipes where needed .
The fittment of the later stat is also important. BUT this isnt what is happening ..... we will always get back seat pundits who know better than everyone else who advise to chuck it back together as cheapily as possible and to sell it on asap .The next owner then purchase the car cheapily and is very happy with it until all of a sudden one day he notices his car is running like a shed and hes in to Land Rover with a £1000 bill ...hence the senario starts all over again .

Back in the early days if the vehicle was in warranty Land Rover were just replacing engines left right and centre especially if the engine had stopped and emulsified everything...the customer was being told that his engine was FUBAR and beyond repair...hence again why so many people believed that head gasket failure meant total engine failure...but we all know ( well some of us ) that wasnt the case .

My advise has stayed the same...if you want to save yourself considerable money then check your coolant religously...it maybe the difference between an engine change or just a repair. I dont just pluck this info out of the air it is a result of stripping these engines down and finding what the hell is going on with them...

My heart goes out to anyone who has had a failure , but i have no sympathy for those who have driven their vehicles to destruction...and lets face it there are alot out there . Do you really think that i was born yesterday to have me believe that a fully trained auto tech / enginner would drive a Freelander to the point of catching fire to a bloody wiring loom just because of a hg failure.... PULL THE OTHER ONE ITS GOT BELLS ON IT !!!

Now , wheres that pear cider !!


___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 9:48 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

dudkat if you are refering to my wifes freelander catching fire ,the one that landrover inspected and came up with the prognosis on well get your facts correct ,my wife was the only driver in the 10 days we owned the car and it is insulting for you to say that she drove it to destruction causing the fire when landrover admitted liability ,although you will argue the toss over that as you seem to be ,A KNOW IT ALL

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:05 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Stu.

Vehicles DONT just "catch" fire due to headgaskets failing Stu ...you know that , i know that , every trained tech out there worth his salt knows that.

If this were the case seeing that Land Rover inspected it there would be without doubt a worldwide recal , seeing as this hasnt happened i think you can safely say this isnt the case .

Now whats this recal you here of , about Land Rovers catching fire ?




___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:09 PM
cbr freelander
Joined 20 Aug 2006
154 posts

stu, your right about the thermostat..
You need to make a modification to one....i think if i remember right you need a 72C thermo, and drill a 3 mm hole in it, so its never fully closed and when its heating up, it does it gently, so as not to suddenly temp shock the head.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:10 PM
Stewart
Joined 13 Jun 2009
114 posts

Thanks Stu. Too much to write every time. That's why I looked for a late model. My VIN is 04 Production. I have previously specified PRT for earlier models, aswell as very importantly - Liner Heights above the Block facing (to keep them SEATED). That's what we found on my MGTF. Loose liners 'hammering' the Cyl Head, and Block base mounts in worse case scenarios. dudkat knows this stuff.
The latest MLS (Multi Layer Steel) HG has:-
a) a vastly improved flexibility (required with the K18 design)
b) complete coverage bonding surfaces as apposed to coolant/oil apperture circumferance only (as earlier HGs)
c) tougher and more flexible fire ring structure
d) steel shim with full bonding coat (upper) fitted between HG and Head face -
eliminates fire ring indentation of softer head face (so called HARDENED Treatment)
NB That's why it important to replace heads on seriously 'Fire Ring "indented" Cyl Head faces'. dudcat - correct me, up to 5thou skim accepted??
dudkat has more K18 experience than I, that's why I wanted to brind the Rover Boff 'Telfer' onto the Forum.

Stu, just hang here and be patient. Electrical fires don't happen with
an Overheat - was broken wiring insulation or a multitude of causes.
I agree, let sleeping dogs rest in peace!
Let the Forum decide, whether to keep looking for Tech solutions in fairness, or to fight a loosing battle fighting with the manufacturer?

I actually find the 'mix' quite interesting.
My blood is also 'Boiling' over the lack of Facory support. Sooner or later, they will appear!

Tell us more dudkat. I find it interesting to read that you are the 'Factory Spy'? You certainly have a broad CV, I am honoured Sir!
cbr is quite right.

Regards,

Stewie - Cape Town.




___________________

Technology is how you apply it....... woodiess - Cape Town.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:14 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

cbr ,the old thermostat that was fitted was one of the reasons the gasket failed especially on short runs where the head was not evenly hot

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:21 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

dudkat ,so why did landrover say that and pay me all money for freelander back and compo ,the recall was on some vin nos of the new freelanders setting fire ,,as for landrover would have a worldwide recall on freelanders setting fire ,i dont think they would as they did not do a worldwide recall on the headgasket situation, lol,ps when they handed over the cheque to me they said i was not allowed to discuss the incicent on my freelander ,so how many people out there paid off to keep quiet

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:21 PM
Stewart
Joined 13 Jun 2009
114 posts

Gr8 stuff dudkat ............. mine's Sauvignon Blanc!

We are on the same sentence, same para in the same book friend!

I and our Factory trained Michael Robinson look forward .......

Regards,

Stewart - Cape Town.




___________________

Technology is how you apply it....... woodiess - Cape Town.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:24 PM
cbr freelander
Joined 20 Aug 2006
154 posts

Stu, if your head wasnt heating evenly, it could have been for a multitude of reasons...Yes a thermo, but if the type i suggested was fitted, the head woudl have longer to heat, thus easing the problem.
I suggest the head was possibly already damaged from a previous overheat, or most likely an airlock...Some parts of the head having water, and some not..Make sense??..I think so.

Adverts Currently On Preloved - Place an ad here for free


FOR SALE
Ford Explorer 4x4 LPG low tax, low running costs
Coalville, Leicestershire, UK
  FOR SALE
Ford Transit County 4x4 Diesel Lwb
Belfast, Antrim, UK
 
FOR SALE
Ford Connect Tdci T230 L Lwb 90 *NEW SHAPE* Panel Vans (Small) 2006 ()
Petersfield, Hampshire, UK
  WANTED
MOTORHOME WANTED
Nottinghamshire, Mansfield, UK
 
 
[More 4x4 ads...]

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:29 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

cbr ,thats what i was saying the old thermostats on the early freelanders caused thermo shock ,

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:39 PM
cbr freelander
Joined 20 Aug 2006
154 posts

Stu, Im just wondering now, if its widely accepted to fit a modified thermo to them, or if its just a little added extra the likes of Dudkat would add in...It was him and a bloke called Des Hammill, who i regard as guru's to the k16 engines, that told me about the thermo mod.
Had my engine not been $hagged, i reckon it would have worked a treat to help the old girl out..
I reckon the k16's are just like a high dependancy woman...gotta give em lots of love and attention, and make sure their fluids are kept topped up!

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:40 PM
Stewart
Joined 13 Jun 2009
114 posts

No No No No No - to 72 deg and drilling holes!!
You ENSURE a PRT (REMOTE THERMSTAT) is fitted.
The original Therm is removed from the housing, and an open restrictor plate is fitted. Comes as a Kit.

Please read dudkat and I SERIOUSLY (after his Cider, and my wine!)

NO QUICK FIXES one by one, WILL ever SOLVE THE K18 ISSUE.

Read it ALL, note it ALL and 'DO IT ALL' and CHECK THE CAUSE OF THE HG FAILURE. Not all HGF is what we can assume! Internal and External
issues. YOU HAVE TO DO THE EXTERNAL STUFF like I have ALWAYS done! Check your levels religiously, and signs of Hose Clamp joints, radiator (stones damage), Oil Cooler Rads and the like.

LEVEL CHECKS, tell in an INSTANT - TROUBLE ??????????????

That'll confuse them - hey dudkat?? Oh well, bottle open, let's finish it!

Rgds.

Stewart - Cape Town.






___________________

Technology is how you apply it....... woodiess - Cape Town.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:48 PM
cbr freelander
Joined 20 Aug 2006
154 posts

Stuart, yeah the remote thermo was an option given to me as well as the time.. But back then, it was a little pie in the sky to me and having to buy extra electronics kit for it seemed a lot of hassle for something that may not have helped...after all, i was like a lot of others at the time, i didnt know if it would help or not...I was following advice blindly looking for a cure....The other option was the much cheaper thermo mod..Which was not a bad idea really when you think it through, and it did work..I didnt try it on mine, but the individual who reccomended it had tried it, with success.
The engine ran cooler, and heated up more slowly and evenly..Sucess in my mind..
But yes stewart, your method is the professional way, if not a bit more expensive.

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:54 PM
Stewart
Joined 13 Jun 2009
114 posts

Hey Stu. LR asked you nicely ....... Sschhhhhhush!

You also might be about to lose you Passport!

Seriously though. Yor darling wife must hav p'd herself wen that lot went up in smoke?

I am ashamed to make fun of it all, but please seriously consider things.
There are a multitude of reasons why.

Most importantly - You and particularly, your darling wife, suffered trauma.

You are alive to FACE THE FORUM, which is nothing compared to LIFE in a Freebie with no problems?

Statistics show that a Hum drum Motoring life can end with Divorce!

Regards,

Stewart - Cape Town.


___________________

Technology is how you apply it....... woodiess - Cape Town.



Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 10:56 PM
Stewart
Joined 13 Jun 2009
114 posts

udkat - may I please copy and paste your last message to me, on the Rover 75 forum - ALL SAME PROBLEM.

Regards,

Stewart - Cape Town.


___________________

Technology is how you apply it....... woodiess - Cape Town.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 11:24 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Stewart.

Yep no probs ...go for it .


___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
9 July 2009, 11:34 PM
-  Edited by DONT BUY A FREELANDER 10 July 2009, 1:54 AM
DONT BUY A FREELANDER
Joined 8 Nov 2008
137 posts

Hi Stu

Everything you say makes sense to me. As I had horendous problems with my Freelander, I understand where you are coming from. Dudkat probably means well, but he is definately wrong defending the Freelander. This 4x4 was made to go wrong.
Why don't you and me go halves on a second hand Freelander I am sure we could get a good one for £2000. Let Dudkat put the multilayer gasket on it, and check it over to make sure he is happy with it. We could then give it to someone impartial, such as my local vicar and see what happens over then next 12 months, if the car fails, then Dudkat has to buy it from us at the original price we paid, plus the cost of repairing it, and supply a hire car for every time the car is off the road, and of course pay for any repairs in that 12 months, but obviously not tyres, exhausts etc, just gearboxes, transferboxes, electrical faults you name it it will probably happen. If the car lasts the 12 months, then we will have to cower our head and agree with Dudkat that he knows best.

What do you think, as you are a solicitor, I am sure you could draw up a legally binding contract.

Kindest Regards

Dont buy a Freelander


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
10 July 2009, 0:06 AM
DONT BUY A FREELANDER
Joined 8 Nov 2008
137 posts

Hi Stu

I always find I agree with you and not Dudkat. Has he ever owned a Freelander.

No car should actually need a low water light, only a low oil light.

But if you own the Freelander or any car fitted with the dreaded 1.8 k series engine, then I would definately agree that a low water light is needed.

I have only been driving for 38 years, none of the car I have driven have had a low water light, only a low oil light.

With the Freelander you would need a low water light, a my gearbox is about to fail light, my cv joint is about to fail light, the transfer box is about to fail light, the electrics are about to catch fire light, the engine mountings are about to fail light, the back window is about to fall out light, the car is not going to start light due to the onboard immobiliser light, the stereo is not going to work properly light, the list goes on, and on, and on, and on, and on, and on, and on and on, and on, and on, and on, and on, and on, and on, and on, and on and on, and on, and on, and on.

The Freelander was truely the worst car I have ever had, and I would definately not buy anything with the Land Rover badge on, and I have just got a new job with a national magazine. And I will definately not be defending anything Land Rover produce - even if they are putting full page adverts in it - if I find hundred of unhappy customers on the forum sites, I will definately be putting the Freelander problems into print, if my editor allows me. And will be highlighting the problems with the Disco 3, check out http://www.landroverhell.com

To Land Rover I would say ''you still have time to put matters right. Just be honest. Honesty is the BEST policy''.

God help you!!!!!!!

DONT BY A FREELANDER

Hopefully this shoud stir things up a little!!!!

I am not sure I will be able to do any more listings, as the new job is 24/7.

I wish you all well, even Dudkat!!!!!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
10 July 2009, 0:13 AM
Stewart
Joined 13 Jun 2009
114 posts

Rob - Solicitor I am not, ex Rhodesian Policeman, yes.
Wotever, an interesting project you suggest.

I am 'skint' having just offloaded 2G on the MG job, let alone the 8500 on the car! Still have not sold the BGT or the Peugeot 206 CC (another hot one!)

Wot do you say dudkat ?

Anyways. Steleeuk has done it. Steleeuk, you are the experiment, and those that have religiously carried out the LATEST SPEC IN ALL RESPECTS!

My thoughts in a nutshell!

My car is also done (plus Liners, rings and crank shells)
- and it is paid for!

dudkat must chat to Telfer (wen he appears) about the mid-engine
downfall - which I beleive, is worse than the LR Freebie and Rover or MG Shopping Trolly issues (Hatchbacks).

Why .......... colder coolant entering the head thermo area (Thermo Shock to Cyl Head that cbr was referring to) This with MG TF and Lotus Elise!

Front engines ran a bit cooler - ha ha. Had the same inflo at the Cyl Head????

I suppose, that I must put some kms on the clock then?

Sleep tite all, and happy motoring.

Stewart - Cape Town.






___________________

Technology is how you apply it....... woodiess - Cape Town.


Messages 3541 to 3560 of 3875.

« Previous  1  ...  172  173  174  175  176  177  178  179  180  181  182  183  184  ...  194  Next »

 

Important Note

All messages are submitted by visitors to this web site, and represent their own personal opinion. They do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of Preloved.

You use this information at your own risk. Preloved can not be held responsible for any damages or loss resulting from the use of this site. Please see our Terms and Conditions for more details.

Not a member yet?

Why not join the fun for free! Members can sell their stuff completely free of charge, have searches prioritised for their local area, and lots more.

Join for free | Member Log In
Are you a fan of Preloved?

If so, why not help us spread the Joy of Second Hand by joining us on Facebook. [more...]