Preloved
ClassifiedsForumsReviewsMembersThe Joy of Second Hand

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure

Messages 3741 to 3760 of 3875.

« Previous  1  ...  182  183  184  185  186  187  188  189  190  191  192  193  194  Next »


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
4 November 2009, 11:38 PM
Stewart
Joined 13 Jun 2009
114 posts

Hallo K18 Freelander Forum, and Robert -

the secret is..........

Do it right, the first time .... with the COMPLETE PARTS LIST - and Bolts !!

Stewart W - Cape Town.

Pik is eventually the Dial, indicating the additional complication.

You will have to wait for the Case Pik.




___________________

Technology is how you apply it....... woodiess - Cape Town.


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 8:24 AM
Mitch
Joined 10 Sep 2008
17 posts

Firstly I have not made anything up. My name is Michelle. Im 30 years old and I have had my LandRover for 2 years ( I love the car) I moved to Switzerland in January 2010 and brought the car with me after the head gasket repair (thinking that all would now be ok)

Im real and my friends call me Mitch. My contact number is 0041796841196 - you can even call it - it works and Ill answer!!!

My comment on `left hand drive`was obvioulsy supposed to be `right hand drive`a simple mistake. Im living in Europe and everyone (if you didnt already know) had left handed vehicles. Mine is right handed and noone here wants to purchase a right hand drive - so Im stuck with the problem - it wont even sell to a 2nd hand dealer as it will cost them too much to convert and they dont want to do the headgasket work too - its too expensive.

I apologise for my left/right handed error. It was supposed to have read - noone wants a right hand drive in Switzerland.

The email I received from LandRover was from: [Log in to view email]

She is real too - I spoke to her!

Its all real and I think youd have to be a pretty sad individual to make this stuff up - I can think of a million better pranks to play on the internet.

This is unfortunately a real issue and my only current option is to get the work done and lay out the 3,700 CHF so I can at least drive the thing,

Landrover should be disgusted with their attitude and their knowledge of this - cant we go to watchdog or something ? Its just a sham

I absolutely love that car and I dont want to get rid of it - but whats the point in keeping something that keeps going wrong.

This is my quote for the work - yes its real too. If you call me Ill even send you the email from the garage.......

(its german and ive translated the main parts)

Ersatzteile

Zylinderkopfdichtung (Cylinder Head Gasket) 1 179.00
Ansaugaggregat Dichtung (Aggregate Intake Gasket) 1 20.90
Auspuffkollektor Dichtung (Exhaust Collector Gasket) 1 22.80
V.D.D ( 1 41.70
Simmering Nockenwelle (Simmering camshaft) 4 66.40
Zylinderkopfschrauben (cylinder head screw) 10 196.00
Auspuffkollektor Bolzen (Exhaust Collector pins) 5 11.50
AuspuffKollektor Mutter (Exhaust collector mother) 5 19.50
Sammelrohr Dichtung (Manifold gasket) 1 3.00
Wasserpumpe (water pump) 1 277.00
Thermostat (Thermostat) 1 178.00
Zahnriemen (belt) 1 141.00
Spannrolle (clamping role) 1 118.00
Oelfilter (oil filter) 1 13.90
Platte Thermostat (Thermostat plate) 1 23.30
Schiene (rail/split/edge/blade) 1 121.00

Motorenöl (Motor oil) 4.5 60.75
Frostschutz (Antifreeze) 4 48.00
---------------
1541.75

7.6% MwSt. 117.15
----------------
Ersatzteile Total 1’658.90
=========
Arbeit

FZ von Arlesheim in Werkstätte überführen (towing to garage) 2.0 278.00
Zylinderkopf demontieren (Cylinder head dissasemble) 2.5 347.50
Zylinderkopf abpressen (Cylinder head squeeze) 113.00
Zylinderkopf planschleifen (Cylinder head grind) 83.00
Ventilschaftabdichtungen ersetzen (replace valve) 1.0 139.00
Zylinderkopf einbauen (Install cylinder head) 3.5 486.50
Wasserpumpe und Zahnriemen A+E ersetzen (Water pump and timing belt replacement A + E)
2.5 347.50
Ölwechsel Motor mit Filter (Engine oil change with filter)
0.6 83.40
Motor und Motorenraum reinigen (Engine and engine room cleaning)
65.00
---------------
1'942.90
7.6% MwSt. 147.65
---------------
Arbeit Total 2'090.55
=======

Ersatzteile 1'658.90
Arbeit 2'090.55
-------------
Reparaturkosten 3'749.45
=======



Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 8:33 AM
Mitch
Joined 10 Sep 2008
17 posts

Ive just read some of your posts properly and seems there is some political debate stuff going on. I just wanted an answer to my problem and if you check back to september 2008 - I posted then also when I had the first problem. I found this forum and posted about the intial head gasket failure I had and thats hwen Landrover paid the 50%.

Im not `joining forces`with anyone on anyones argument. Im sure some gaskets work and maybe others dont. I posted the email I got from the garage yesterday from Guy Salmon Stockport.

I live in Switzerland now and seems that I dont have many `rights`with the UK to claim etc. Im literally 7 weeks out of the warranty with the last head gasket and last time round I was just our of the new cars 3 year warranty . so I guess Im just unlucky

Im not taking sides - and I do love my car. I just wanted to let you know what my personal situation is and to ask for advice - because I didnt know what the best thing to do was and thought maybe this forum could help me

Thanks


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 8:39 AM
Mitch
Joined 10 Sep 2008
17 posts

Ive even added a photo - look....Im real!!

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 5:56 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

hi mitch,,i will read all your info later on and give you honest advise as what i would do ,i have a wife who is a solicitor also so will have a look later on and give you a reply ,,i also think dont buy a freelander needs a big big apology off certain members on here who seem to be bullying him ,,its a free country and he has the right to a opinion like every one else on here ,,certain members are making this site a embarresment ,,they need to put a line under there differences with dont buy a freelander ,,and stick to giving great technical info ,,very sorry mitch about all this going on will mail you later on ,,,ps,,i am very surprised with your looks they did not put a engine in for free ,,lol


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 6:08 PM
-  Edited by steleeuk 5 November 2009, 6:11 PM
steleeuk
Joined 9 Jul 2008
44 posts

Hello Mitch ! ok i stand corrected, sorry your having such a bad time with your l/r as i said i had the head gasket done on mine over 18 months ago and its been great ever since so your right when you say for some the repair works and others it dont work,My m8 has a BMW he got new last year and he has has problem after problem and i always thought BMW were really reliable..some1 else i know has a Nissan Nivrana and it seems they have bad axel problems as he has had very expensive problems with his, all im saying is it seems theres lots of well known makes that aint as reliable as they used to be.

hope you get sorted soon tho !

ps i wouldnt go round putting your phone number on the net,see if you can edit it out .


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 6:23 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

hi mitch, what i would do is contact the dealer that did the repair for you and ask for all the money that you paid out back for the bodgy repair, if they dont offer it back say that you are going to get an engineers report (£50) and report off the garage in switzerland and take them to county court in england which would cost about £80, you will probably win. Make sure that you have all got calls logged and any correspondance should be sent registered post and keep a copy.

Contact Landrover in UK and explain what has happened, what are they going to help you as the problem shouldn't arise again after 13 months. if they dont help you tell them that you will not buy landrover again and send copies of everything to honest john out of the daily telegraph in the UK, he will publish your problem in the sunday paper and hopefully disgrace them into helping you.

I would repair the car in the UK but not in switzerland as it would probably struggle to pass all the emission tests etc.

As a damage limitation exercise I would try and get as much money back as I could, ask the dealer where it is at the minute what he would give you for it as it stands, you could also put it on ebay in switzerland you may get a good price from someone who knows about cars.

Do the above and walk away, cut your losses and get a left hand drive where you are, it is safer.,,,,regards stu


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 6:25 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Dont buy.

Would you care to state where i have said that these engines dont suffer anymore from hg failure anymore? You wont be able to because i have never said that... i have always said that IF these engines are to be repaired then they need to meet the correct criteria...if they do and all of the correct modified parts are used then there is no reason why they cant be sucessfully repaired and in 2.5 years have had NO repeat failures.

You have no idea that Mitchs repaired was carried out correctly...you have no idea that there wasnt an underlying fault left undiagnosed...you have no idea that that the Tech who carried out the repair may have known as much as you...which, incidently you could write on a postage stamp.

Ive given this forum years of good service...if you think that a few ill informed posting from yourself will make me post anything different then you are very mistaken.
Mitches post proves nothing ...youre just to daft to realise that.



___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 6:30 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

you would think that a landrover main dealer charging 2800 pounds would do the repair correctly .god it makes my blood boil the misery landrover put on people like mitch

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 6:49 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Mitch.

If i have misjudged your posting then i apologise.

Legality isnt my forte so iam unable to advise you on that however, with regards to your repair Land Rover only ever make one goodwill contribution...and that is dependent on the circumstances ie service history etc etc ...normally they will contribute aslong as the vehicle is under 40 months old.
If your hg has failed again then you have 3 options imo. Go buy Des Hamills book about this subject and get it repaired by a reputable garage who have knowledge of this engine...give them the book and tell them you want it repaired as per the instructions .
It will cost you ...however that is one option...

The other is to sell it as seen without the hg being fixed and lose more money....

Or thirdly spend 2 years of your life preparing a pointless website telling us all about how the vehicle as wrecked your life and ruined your marriage , spend more money on trying to take them to court and setting a " TASK FORCE " up which is about as much use as breasts on a nun.

Land Rover have and will continue to evade any court action over this...the horse as well and truly bolted.

I would love to tell you that there is light at the end of the tunnel but there isnt...you either have to accept it and do what you think is best OR let it ruin your life and spend years trying to get justice.

By the way...i agree with the previous post and try and delete your telephone number.


___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Adverts Currently On Preloved - Place an ad here for free


FOR SALE
HYUNDAI TERRACAN 4X4
Bromsgrove, Worcestershire, UK
  OTHER
3wheeler pushchairs
Everywhere, UK
 
WANTED
MOTORHOME WANTED
Nottinghamshire, Mansfield, UK
  FOR SALE
FORD RANGER 4X4 DOUBLE CAB AIRCON BLACK Panel Vans (Large) 2003 ()
Clutton, Bristol, Gloucestershire, UK
 
 
[More 4x4 ads...]

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 7:14 PM
stu
Joined 1 Sep 2008
117 posts

dudkat,,where is dont buy a freelanders apology

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 8:13 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Stu.

Apology for what ?


___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 9:59 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

you would think that a landrover main dealer charging 2800 pounds would do the repair correctly .god it makes my blood boil the misery landrover put on people like mitch.

Yeh youre right you should be able to think that but mistakes are made and things are left unchecked......price doesnt come into it.



___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 11:22 PM
DONT BUY A FREELANDER
Joined 8 Nov 2008
137 posts

Dudkat

Blimey, so many if's!! Are you sure you know what your talking about!

First of all your telling me that Mitch was not a genuine contributor.

Now your sort of telling me that there could be a problem, but definately not if the repair was carried out correctly, well Mitch did have her head gasket repaired by a Land Rover agent. If they can't do the job properly, who can.

As regards my knowledge on the matter, I certainly have more than a postage stamp full!

Let just agree to disagree.

Watch out there are prats about who tell us that the Freelander does not have a head gasket problem if repaired correctly. LOL!! LOL!! LOL!! LOL!!

The cars a LEMON, I know, I had one!!!!

If you want to loose a lot of money, buy a Freelander!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 11:39 PM
-  Edited by DONT BUY A FREELANDER 5 November 2009, 11:41 PM
DONT BUY A FREELANDER
Joined 8 Nov 2008
137 posts

Stu

I have only met a few people in my life like Dudkat - thank god!

He obviously lives in a different world to me.

His world: Freelanders head gaskets don't blow (if the repair is done correctly), Land Rover top of the reliability surveys!

We all know Land Rover make very very unreliable cars, just check the reliability tables on the internet. And of course the Freelander is probably the worst 4x4 ever made, that suffered so, so many head gasket failures. The head gasket problem has definately not been sorted.

Anyway his comments are just water of a ducks back to me!!

Keep on throwing the insults Dudkat, I can take them!!

Hopefully Dudkat will cut out the bad language.



Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
5 November 2009, 11:47 PM
DONT BUY A FREELANDER
Joined 8 Nov 2008
137 posts

Dudkat

Mitch had to list her phone number etc. Because certain idiots on this forum thought it was all made up.

Watch out the are idiots about!!!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
6 November 2009, 0:56 AM
DONT BUY A FREELANDER
Joined 8 Nov 2008
137 posts

Dudkat, this is what you said:

''We were very early stages with the MLS headgasket , back then the early signs looked very good and have stayed that way also which is promising. We still have not had any repeat failures as yet bearing in mind its nearly 2 1/2 yrs ago since the first were fitted.''

Watch out there is a prat about saying the Freelanders he has repaired have had no repeat failures in nearly 2.5 years.

Why not let Land Rover know, how you did it! They don't seem to be as good as you in the head gasket repair department!

I personally DON'T BELIEVE YOU!!

Too many people on this website with too many head gaskets blown. Now we have Mitch's headgasket problem, repaired by Land Rover and now failed again!



Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
6 November 2009, 8:16 AM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Dudkat, this is what you said:
''We were very early stages with the MLS headgasket , back then the early signs looked very good and have stayed that way also which is promising. We still have not had any repeat failures as yet bearing in mind its nearly 2 1/2 yrs ago since the first were fitted.

Absolutely....so where did i say that they dont fail anymore ?....read my words..If you look at what ive wrote i have said we have not had any repeat failures AS YET, which means that in the early stages we were still unsure and until such times i see a failed MLS headgasket which i have been involved in i will continue to write and advise to that effect.

You are doing nothing for the people on this forum...nothing at all, your ill advise conjecture leaves people confused and not knowing which way to turn with this problem...if a new member came on here now they would be stuffed, which makes me personally very very angry. They wont get help from Land Rover and if this continues they will no longer be getting any help or advice from me.




___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
6 November 2009, 8:57 AM
Mitch
Joined 10 Sep 2008
17 posts

Thanks all. I have to make a decision by Monday and let the garage here know what to do . Im travelling back to the UK today so I may go into LR where I had the repair done and discuss with them a little further. I dont think I can edit an old post to remove the number but ill try later anyway as rushing now. Im going to read all the posts later and discuss with my Dad in the UK about what to do. I just want the easiest option at this point as although its a horrible huge shame the repairs dont seem worth it. The 7000 odd CHF to get it driving over here isnt worth it. I asked the garage if they would buy it off me and he said no!!!! He worked it out and he said if he did the work and registered it through the swiss emissions tests etc then he would finally make a 3400 CHF loss!!!! So its repair (at my costs) or scrap!! Ill update you Monday and will read all your advice fully later. Thank you

Land Rover Freelander Head Gasket Failure
6 November 2009, 12:04 PM
dudkat72
Joined 6 Mar 2006
906 posts

Stu.

You wrote.......

they need to put a line under there differences with dont buy a freelander ,,and stick to giving great technical info

May i ask how that great info can now be achieved when other members are constantly disagreeing with that info ? I have seen the possitive aspects of the MLS headgskets for ages but the engine must be not to badly damaged from the previous failure.

How many of you out there have ever had one of these engines apart, how many of you have spent ours putting these engines back together?

Until you have had one apart , have repaired it to spec using all of the correct parts and then have seen a failure of the new MLS gasket with your own eyes no-one can come on here and say the repair isnt working.

That is the reason why i always suspect the original repair wasnt done correctly or something was left undiagnosed when there is a repeat failure.




___________________

Watch out theres a clown about !!


Messages 3741 to 3760 of 3875.

« Previous  1  ...  182  183  184  185  186  187  188  189  190  191  192  193  194  Next »

 

Important Note

All messages are submitted by visitors to this web site, and represent their own personal opinion. They do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of Preloved.

You use this information at your own risk. Preloved can not be held responsible for any damages or loss resulting from the use of this site. Please see our Terms and Conditions for more details.

Not a member yet?

Why not join the fun for free! Members can sell their stuff completely free of charge, have searches prioritised for their local area, and lots more.

Join for free | Member Log In